Michigan’s Two Poison Ivy Species

Toxicodendron radicans

Eastern Poison Ivy

Toxicodendron rydbergii

Western Poison Ivy: left side shows a toothless form. The black dots are dried droplets of urushiol oil. It is milky white when fresh but dries black.

There are two species of Poison Ivy in Michigan. Both species of Poison Ivy have leaves with three leaflets that are notched with large teeth. The lateral leaflets are short stalked and the terminal leaflet has a longer stalk. The teeth are normally found on half of the leaflet, the half closest to the tip. The alternate (singly along the stem) leaves are smooth above, normally shiny and normally they are larger than the leaves of other three leaflet plants. Poison Ivy fruit is a whitish-grayish drupe. (A drupe is a fleshy fruit encasing a seed, for example a cherry or peach). Birds and deer eat the fruit and disperse the seeds.

Toxicodendron radicans

Eastern Poison Ivy

Toxicodendron rydbergii

Western Poison Ivy

Poison Ivy in the winter is recognized by its hairy, grayish, lateral buds with half-rounded or shield shaped leaf scars. There are no stipule scars. The terminal buds end in an abrupt point. Twigs are normally gray but can also have a reddish (or even a greenish) tint. The twigs have many lenticels (dots on twigs) and their pattern is distinct but difficult to describe. If it is Eastern Poison Ivy then it will normally climb and have aerial rootlets without tendrils. The urushiol oil is present in all parts of the plant including the bark and buds so you are not safe from poison ivy in the winter. See blog post for winter twig terminology.

Poison Ivy is in the Anacardiaceae (Cashew or Sumac family). Most of the family’s 800 species are tropical. They include the Cashew, Pistachio, and Mango. Eight species grow wild in Michigan, seven are native.

Although nothing controls common names, the name Poison Oak is best used for species that do not occur in Michigan. Western or Pacific Poison Oak (Toxicodendron diversilobum) occurs along the west coast of the United States. Atlantic poison oak (Toxicodendron pubescens) grows in the southeastern United States.

Toxicodendron radicans

Eastern Poison Ivy

Eastern Poison Ivy (Toxicodendron radicans), in Michigan, is found mainly south of West Branch. It is a vine that can creep along the ground or climb trees. I have seen branches over three feet (1m) long sticking out from the climbing vine, giving the appearance of a Poison Ivy tree. Sometimes, if it lacks a support, it will form a small shrub. It grows in swamp-forests, floodplains, upland woods, and gardens.

Eastern Poison Ivy, according to William Gillis, “Is distributed from southern Canada to western Guatemala, the eastern third of the United States and throughout Mexico, on Bermuda, and in the western Bahamas, in Japan, western and central China and Taiwan, the Kurile Islands and Sakhalin of the U.S.S.R.” He recognized nine subspecies with the Michigan plants belonging to the subspecies negundo.  Negundo refers to Box-elder (Acer negundo) which this plant resembles. (See blog post.)

Toxicodendron radicans

Eastern Poison Ivy

Toxicodendron radicans

Eastern Poison Ivy

Eastern Poison Ivy has petioles (leaf stalks) with fine hairs and they are normally shorter than the leafblade is long. Leaflets are flat and narrower than Western Poison Ivy. Normally they are longer than they are wide. Its fruits are smaller than Western Poison Ivy and tend to be grayish-white. Flowering and fruiting clusters hang and normally have 25 or more flowers or fruits in each cluster.

Toxicodendron rydbergi

Western Poison Ivy

Toxicodendron rydbergii

Western Poison Ivy

Western Poison Ivy (Toxicodendron rydbergii) grows north of the Saginaw-Muskegon line but does occur along most of Lake Michigan’s coastline. It is a small woody plant without aerial rootlets so it never climbs. Its petioles (leaf stalks) are glabrous and they are normally longer than Eastern Poison Ivy. Leaflets are cupped and broad, close to as long as they are wide. Its fruits are larger than Eastern Poison Ivy and tend to be whiter. Flowering and fruiting clusters are held upright and seldom droop. They contain few flowers, normally less than 20 in each cluster. It  grows in sand dunes, along railroads, on road shoulders, and edges of woods. It is found in sand or gravel. Eastern Poison Ivy is normally in richer soil.

Toxicodendron rydbergii

Western Poison Ivy

Hybrids between Eastern and Western Poison Ivy are known and occur along the band where the two species overlap. They are intermediate between the two species.

The two species are normally quite distinct. However, please note the number of times I wrote “normally” when contrasting these two species. Look at a number of characters before deciding which species you are dealing with. I posted this more to illustrate the range of variation in Poison Ivy in Michigan and to explain why it looks different in the northern or southern parts of the state. Caution: These remarks concern Poison Ivy in Michigan, the species vary more outside of the state. Once again, if in doubt, don’t touch it.
Copyright 2015 by Donald Drife

Webpage Michigan Nature Guy
Follow MichiganNatureGuy on Facebook

Poison Ivy Lookalikes

Toxicodendron radicans

Eastern Poison Ivy

Toxicodendron radicans

Eastern Poison Ivy

Recently, I was shown three photos of plants that a person thought were Poison Ivy. Only one was correctly identified.  I searched Google Images for Poison Ivy and found several other species that resemble it. The old adage “leaflets three let it be” will keep you away from Poison Ivy and many harmless species.

Toxicodendron rydbergii

Western Poison Ivy

There are two species of Poison Ivy in Michigan. Eastern Poison Ivy (Toxicodendron radicans) is found mainly south of the Saginaw-Muskegon line. It is a vine that can creep along the ground or climb trees. It is one of two natives that have aerial rootlets. (The other is Virginia Creeper (Parthenocissus quinquefolia) ). Western Poison Ivy (Toxicodendron rydbergii) grows north of the Saginaw-Muskegon line. It is a small woody plant without aerial rootlets so it never climbs. Both species of  Poison Ivy have leaves with three leaflets that are notched with large teeth. The teeth are normally found on half of the leaflet, the half closest to the tip. The alternate (singly along the stem) leaves are smooth above and normally shiny.

Acer negundo

Boxelder

Boxelder (Acer negundo) has opposite leaves (leaves in pairs on stem). Its twigs often have a bluish bloom and it is never a vine. Normally its leaves have finer teeth than Poison Ivy.  Last weekend, I was at Tawas Point State Park and set up to photograph what I thought was Western Poison Ivy only to discover that it was a Boxelder.

Rubus

Dewberry and Raspberry (Rubus)

Bramble, Raspberry, and Blackberry (Rubus) often have prickles along the stem.  They also might have leaflets with pronounced points. Their leaflet edges are uniformly toothed with fine teeth.

Parthenocissus quinquefolia

Virginia Creeper

Virginia Creeper (Parthenocissus quinquefolia) has five leaflets not three. It will have aerial rootlets such as Eastern Poison Ivy. If you find it in fruit its berries are purple and not grayish-white like Poison Ivy

Amphicarpaea bracteata

Hog Peanut

Hog Peanut (Amphicarpaea bracteata) has three leaflets but they are untoothed. It rarely climbs trees and has a finer stem then Poison Ivy.

Fragaria virginiana

Common Strawberry

Common Strawberry (Fragaria virginiana) has blunt leaflets with their teeth uniformly spaced. Their leaf stems are furry and they never creep like Poison Ivy vines do.

Rhus aromatica

Fragrant Sumac

Fragrant Sumac (Rhus aromatica) leaves have numerous blunt teeth and small lobes on their edges. Catkins, or buds of catkins, often appear at the ends of the stems.

 

The best time to learn the lookalikes is when they are flowering or fruiting. Study their leaves and the leaves of Poison Ivy. If in doubt, don’t touch it.

Thanks to Jason for inspiring this blog.
Copyright 2015 by Donald Drife

Webpage Michigan Nature Guy
Follow MichiganNatureGuy on Facebook

Poison Ivy Rust (Pileolaria brevipes) in Michigan

Pileolaria brevipesToxicodendron radicans

Poison Ivy Rust

When I found this growth on a poison ivy vine in Tenhave Woods, Royal Oak, Michigan, I did not know if it was an insect gall, a fungus growth, or a rust. Because it was growing on Poison Ivy (Toxicodendron radicans sensu stricto) , I did not closely examine it. I searched the internet for “rust Toxicodendron radicans,” “rust Rhus radicans,”  and “galls” using both names with no luck. I studied the growths during the remainder of the summer and I was fairly certain that it was a rust.

I recently revisited the photos. Winter months are spent sorting and identifying photos. After searching the Internet for “rust poison ivy,” I found what looked like my poison ivy rust on Iowa State University’s Ada Herbarium website. It was under the name Pileolaria brevipes. This name lead me to an article by David Senchina titled “Fungal and animal associates of Toxicodendron spp. (Anacardiaceae) in North America” with photographs of my poison ivy rust.

Poison IvyPileolaria brevipesToxicodendron radicans Flowers  Rust on flowering Poison Ivy

Poison Ivy Rust on flowering Poison Ivy

Rusts are a small group of parasitic fungi consisting of approximately 7000 species worldwide. Somewhere around 175 species occur in Michigan. Rusts are so-named because their spores are often orange or reddish-brown. They can cause severe damage to important agricultural and timber crops.

Rust fungi have fascinating and complex lifecycles. They can have up to six different spore states during their lifecycle and may need two distinct host plants during their lifecycle (heteroecious) or a single species (autoecious). A rust species usually grows on a specific host species or group of species.

Here is a simplified Wheat Rust lifecycle. It is a heteroecious species with Wheat and Barberry serving as hosts. Wheat Rust over-winters in the soil as a thick-walled spore. They germinate in the spring and produce other spores of two strains (or sexes) that are carried by the wind to the upper surface of Barberry leaves. These grow and produce another type of spore that infects the lower surface of the leaf. From this growth, spores are produced that the wind carries to Wheat. When the rust grows on its Wheat host it produces spores that can directly infect other Wheat plants and then in the fall it produces the over-wintering spores. For a detailed life-cycle of the Wheat Rust and more information on rusts see the University of Hawaii’s Botany Department website.

Poison Ivy Rust’s lifecycle is simpler having just three spore types and a single host plant. It is widespread across most of North America.

There is no popular field guide for Michigan’s rust species. George Cummins and Yasuyuki Hiratsuka produced an Illustrated Genera of Rust Fungi allowing the identification of rust to genus using microscopic characters. My research for this blog has taught me that I see more rust species than I have previously noticed.
Copyright 2013 by Donald Drife

Webpage Michigan Nature Guy
Follow MichiganNatureGuy on Facebook